SUPER-SIZING CAN BE A GOOD THING.
Maybe not for your waistline, but possibly for your Rotary experience.
If you haven’t yet, you will come upon new club members who switched to the Rotary Club of Tucson from another Tucson-area club. Occasionally, a member leaves RCOT for one of our cousin clubs. It’s not always the time of day, day of the week, meeting location or meal quality that is behind swapping clubs. It might be that that person likes the “feel” of our club better.
That feel is made up of one or more factors that distinguish the personality of Rotary Club A from that of Rotary Club B. Pinpointing a factor can be quite a challenge. You may not be able to enumerate the qualities you prefer, but you know them when you experience them.
One factor that is quite easily recognizable and measurable is size. Rotary clubs in our town vary dramatically in membership numbers, from our own 232 (most in Arizona) to fewer than 10.
Clubs are all following the same avenues of service; nevertheless, they take necessarily different routes based upon club member count.
Why do some Rotarians prefer a small, even tiny, club? Typically, joining a small club means immediate, heavy, hands-on involvement. You could find yourself chairing a committee within a week or two. Or chairing three committees, while simultaneously being a member of four more. It’s not unheard of for an 18-month member of a small club to be selected as President-Elect. Presidents have been known to serve two – or more – consecutive terms. The bureaucracy is minimal and decision-making can be rapid, even unilateral. For many, the best part of a club without a triple-digit membership is the speed at which you get to know your fellow club members. It’s measured in weeks, rather than months (or even years in the case of the world’s largest Rotary club which has more than 600 members).
Some of that sounds appealing (a stint as President for 24 or 36 straight months, maybe not). Yet many prefer to join a large Rotary club where there often are certain advantages over a small club.
Need 100+ volunteers to carry out a project? Your huge club can potentially pull that off without reaching out to three degrees of separation beyond the membership. The skill set present in a collection of hundreds of members is undeniably greater than in a group of thirty. If there is a talent we need, it’s probably in hand. If there is an outside contact we need to engage, it’s likely someone in RCOT knows that person.
Large clubs provide inherent back-up in the volunteer pool. Temporary illness or relocation of one person doesn’t present as much of a challenge to continuing a project. Losing a member or two is not normally an existential threat. Having many experienced members provides a readily-available source of mentorship and institutional knowledge so valuable to any association. Do non-Rotary demands on your life mean your Rotary participation level must vary from month to month, or even year to year? The club will be better able to handle your up and down involvement, offsetting your peaks and valleys with those of your fellow Rotarians.
More often than not, the big clubs attract higher-caliber speakers and make a more dramatic public relations impact, both of which shine a larger community spotlight on Rotary’s work (and help all Rotary clubs attract new members).
No one should underestimate the power of the dollar in achieving the good Rotary is known for. It is nearly always true that the larger clubs have greater financial resources. It takes volunteer time – and volunteer money – to successfully complete many of our undertakings. Rotary’s biggest clubs often put to use collective dues dollars to engage a staff, bringing expertise and consistency to the organization. Members are not forced to do club work they find to be unrewarding. And, there is no substitute for the advantages of foundations affiliated with Rotary locals. These 501(c)(3) powerhouses almost always spring from, and are grown by, large clubs.
When viewed solely on the basis of member count, big club versus small club is a matter of your comfort and your situation. Remember, number of members is only one difference between Rotary clubs. Personality is almost always more significant than roster size in making a club right for you.